Hiring senior leaders in today’s fast-changing business landscape has become mission critical. Businesses now need visionary leaders — individuals who can anticipate change and help future-proof their organisation, drive competitiveness, and effectively and proactively manage risks.
The costs of a poor executive hire not only disrupt a company’s growth trajectory but can also lead to substantial setbacks. McKinsey and Co. reports that 27-46% of executive transitions are considered failures or disappointments after two years. CNBC has also noted that ‘failed CEO appointments’ are surging across the globe. With so much change and disruption, the pressing question remains — how do you get a senior hire right?
Gaining a clearer understanding of what it takes for C-suite executives to thrive is crucial, as is conducting thorough background screenings. A recent Gartner survey indicates that leadership development will remain the top priority for HR leaders for the third consecutive year in 2025. This underscores the growing demand for comprehensive vetting methods that ensure only the most qualified individuals are selected for these influential roles.
Need talent? Post jobs to 500,000+ locals now. Find your next hire on MyCareersFuture today.
Companies must make sure that any executive hire can handle the pressure of modern leadership while not impacting their teams. Research highlights that poor leadership is costly. A recent Gallup study revealed that the global cost of disengaged employees has shot up to a staggering $11.46 trillion annually. The ripple effects of poor C-suite leadership are far-reaching, extending to workforce culture, operational efficiency, and ultimately, the company’s bottom line.
Why executive background screening is now non-negotiable
In Singapore, the former Citiraya CEO is being investigated for 150 offences in an embezzlement case involving more than $72 million. Cases like this emphasise the importance of thorough background checks in leadership recruitment.
Rigorous checks also serve as a guiding light through the sea of applicants HR leaders receive, who must remain diligent in their selection process. Once they have their top candidates, they can safeguard the business by hiring only the most qualified leader — using a robust background screening checklist to ensure nothing is overlooked.
What’s behind a leadership background check?
When performing an executive leadership background check, businesses must ensure a strategic approach to safeguard their organisation and employees from potential harm. Below, we outline our checklist to help you better conduct your executive background screening:
5 key components for effective executive screening
1. Validate career achievements
A leader’s track record can highlight potential areas of concern and indicate whether a candidate is truly suited for the role. Just as important is validating past accomplishments to ensure they haven’t been exaggerated or fabricated.
Post your job and reach thousands of active jobseekers in Singapore.
2. Go beyond the resume
Certain leadership roles may require specialised training. In such cases, employers should ensure that all academic qualifications and professional credentials are thoroughly verified before making a hire.
3. Scan financial and criminal backgrounds for red flags
For roles with financial oversight, employers should make rigorous financial and criminal background checks a standard part of the hiring process. This helps to uphold organisational integrity and prevent potential exposure to risk.
4. Perform reputation and reference checks
Interviews do not always uncover the truth about a candidate. References and learning more about an executive’s reputation can speak volumes. They reveal the executive’s ability to foster a positive environment and uphold ethical standards.
5. Review potential conflicts of interest
Conflicts of interest can arise if an executive has a directorship or significant shareholdings in other companies. It is key to check this aspect of a new leadership hire very carefully when conducting searches to identify any potential conflicts.
Strengthen your hiring process today
Companies and HR leaders don’t have to do this all on their own. They can work with partners or leverage technology.
Implementing the above measures within their leadership hiring process will help them protect the organisation from the negative impact of unsuccessful appointments, mitigate risks, and build trust among employees and partners.
This article is contributed by RMI.
