Can a lengthy job application process tick jobseekers off? Yes. Multiple rounds of interviews followed by clearance and administrative procedures can stretch the process over weeks. In Singapore, the average is 68 days, according to a study by Randstad. The same study revealed that 89% of Singaporeans would reject an offer if the process took over four weeks. Now imagine having just interview rounds spanning a month?
Since making the best hiring decision is the goal for any recruiter, ensuring they lock in the ideal candidate for the role requires rigorous analysis, which can take more than an interview. While some organisations in Singapore keep interviews to just one, there are plenty that set out a longer process, often in line with HR policies. For instance, candidates can be interviewed by the team lead on the first round, then with the team head and perhaps have the final one with an HR manager involved. It could also go vice-versa.
Why too many interviews can be a problem
The longer the interview process, the higher chance you might lose your top candidates, says Dr John Sullivan, notable HR thought-leader from the Silicon Valley. While you extend the time taken to make a decision, you might see the potential good quality hires making their exit for significant reasons:
- They received a better offer while interviewing for the role in your company.
- Rejecting an offer elsewhere to continue interviewing for your company may compromise their financial stability.
- Choosing to keep interviewing for your company multiple times is exasperating, especially when a successful hire is not guaranteed.
How many interviews is too many?
When mapping out your interview strategy, you need to understand that candidates put their career development as top priority throughout the job search process. What employers can do is to be mindful of jobseekers’ needs. In the words of Randstad’s Global CEO Michael Smith, “Employers should adopt a needs-based approach towards recruitment by placing the job seekers’ career objectives and goals first.” Especially in the present volatile job market, showing empathy goes a long way in reducing the stress and anxiety faced by many jobseekers today.
So how many interviews is too many? That rests on the nature of the role you’re seeking talent for. Having three to four interviews just for an entry-level position may frustrate candidates but the number is sufficient for a more senior role. In the event where more than four or five rounds of interviews are required, it is best to provide a justification.
Hiring managers must also consider the number of candidates to interview, time taken to process application documents and clearance procedures following the interviews. The longer it takes to complete the rounds, the later the candidate signs the contract and starts the job. This may affect internal teams who need the extra manpower as soon as they can.
Interview tips for hiring managers
Here are some tips to make the best of the interview process so you can decide on the ideal hire:
1. Start evaluating the candidate before the interview
This allows you to narrow down to more specific questions you could ask to fully ascertain the candidate’s capabilities instead of generic interview questions. Take the common interview questions and adapt accordingly.
2. Make the most of the interview
Gather all the information you can in the first interview itself and make notes. Listen to the candidate’s responses. Develop follow-up questions that are critical to the role but those that are well within your means. If there is a response specific to a task, leave that for the team to question further. This is something you should advise all interviewers beforehand.
3. Coordinate with other interviewers
A good interview is not only one that is well-planned but also well-executed. Having all the interviewers at the panel on the same page is important and this requires information-sharing. When each interviewer has a good snapshot of the candidate before the interview, they avoid wasting time asking questions they already have information for. Based on the information they have, they can instead delve deeper and sieve out more details to prove the candidate’s worth.
Check out more tips here!